Skip to Main Content
  • Cara's Cookie Company logo top
    Cara's Cookie Company logo scroll
  • Menu
  • Drinks
  • Custom Orders
    Cookie Cake Inquiry Personalized Sugar Cookie Inquiry
  • Order
  • Parties
  • Catering
  • Jobs
  • About us
  • Specials
  • Events
  • Instagram pageGoogle page
Cara's Cookie Company logo topCara's Cookie Company logo scroll
  • Instagram pageGoogle page
  • Menu
  • Drinks
  • Custom Orders
    Cookie Cake Inquiry Personalized Sugar Cookie Inquiry
  • Order
  • Parties
  • Catering
  • Jobs
  • About us
  • Specials
  • Events

Our Menu

CookiesMerchandiseSweetsWholesale Pastries

Menu

Cookies photo

Cookies

$3.00/+
4oz Cookies $3.00 | 8oz Cookies $5.00
Cookie Pushpops photo

Cookie Pushpops

$5.00
Layers of sugar or chocolate chip cookie with icing inbetween. Customize your order with advance notice for your upcoming events!
Personalized Sugar Cookies photo

Personalized Sugar Cookies

varies
We can handle anything you can dream up or replicate anything you can find and send us. Let us make some logo cookies for your company or small business too! Pricing varies. Require 7 day notice.
Cookie Cakes photo

Cookie Cakes

$40.00/+
Any cookie flavor we make, in a cake. Regular single layer (3.5lb) $40.00 | Double layer (7lb) $65.00 • Tier Cookie Cakes for weddings, showers, etc... , CONTACT US PLEASE Require 7 day notice.
Gingerbread Oatmeal Whiskey Cream Pie photo

Gingerbread Oatmeal Whiskey Cream Pie

$6.00
*Seasonal, filling contains alcohol. Please message us for all orders for these if not in December. 7 day notice.
Cara's Cookie Art Kit photo

Cara's Cookie Art Kit

$10.00
Includes 2 cookies and brush. Dip brush in water, pick a color, decorate your cookies and eat! Let's customize the templates for your event!
Business Logo Cookies! photo

Business Logo Cookies!

$5.00
Your brand, our sugar cookies! 7 day notice, any cookie amount!
Irish Whoopie Pies! photo

Irish Whoopie Pies!

$6.00
March is here and so are our HUGE whoopie pies made with Bailey's Irish cream (filling) and 2 pillowy soft, chocolate cakes made with Guinness Irish Stout! *contains alcohol. Please meassage us if not in March, 7 day notice.

Items

Hats photo

Hats

$25.00
Shirts photo

Shirts

$20.00
Wristbands photo

Wristbands

$2.00

Menu

Fudge photo

Fudge

$7.50/8oz
*7 days notice* Chocolate (with/without pecans), peanut butter cup, cookies and cream

Wholesale Pastries

Wholesale Pastries

$3.50
Sweet and savory scones, cinnamon rolls and muffins. Variety of flavors, seasonal options and even special flavors just for your business to stand out! Let's chat!
  • Order
  • Parties
  • Catering
  • Jobs